THE WEEKLY READER
Feminist reads, every Saturday morning.
Who Does “West Side Story” Really Serve?
by Rosa Catagena
The original West Side Story (1961) film confused me when I first watched it as a kid, some 40 years after its release. Too young to understand racist stereotypes and brownface, I didn’t recognize these Puerto Ricans, not their voices nor their motivations, at all. It was Anita’s sharpest lyric that was most puzzling: “Puerto Rico / My heart’s devotion / Let it sink back in the ocean.” Unlike composer Stephen Sondheim, who admitted to being entirely unfamiliar with the people he wrote about, I actually knew Nuyoricans and DiaspoRicans—and not once had I ever heard them express such disgust and revulsion for the island. (The stage musical’s initial lyrics called Puerto Rico an “ugly island” of “tropical diseases.”) Still, the film won 10 Oscars, including Best Picture; but despite its groundbreaking mainstream representation of Puerto Ricans, it both mischaracterized and misunderstood the diaspora. Our own Rosa Cartagena reviews the new West Side Story.
1. In thinking about Women’s History Month, our staff decided to dedicate this month’s BitchReads list to some of the essential books that have shaped our thinking and growth as feminists. Our recommendations include fantastical fiction (Sailor Moon and The Parable of the Sower), necessary feminist works (from Angela Davis and bell hooks), and revolutionary texts (The Red Record and Zami). As always, happy reading! [Rosa Cartagena]
2. But as the images of war dominated news coverage and social media platforms, it was difficult to avoid noticing how my friends and other young people online were reacting. There were plenty of infographics going around with various takes on the theme of “How Americans Can Help Support Ukraine Right Now.” People shared links to fundraising efforts to collect money for Ukrainian children, the Armed Forces, or general humanitarian relief. Many were also changing their profile photos to the Ukrainian flag—made up of the national colors of blue and yellow. This was vaguely reminiscent of what occurred online on June 2, 2020, when millions of Instagram users posted black squares to “stand up” to police brutality in the wake of George Floyd’s death: an action that was largely interpreted as shallow, performative, and irrelevant to the bigger fight for racial justice. [Stacia Datskovskaarah]
3. Anastasia Higginbotham is an author and artist who crafts her books by hand using recycled materials like brown paper bags, cloth, and jewelry. Her children’s series, Ordinary Terrible Things, centers on young characters confronting difficult formative experiences such as death, divorce, abuse, and white supremacy that shape their identities in various ways. Her book about race, Not My Idea: A Book About Whiteness (2018), infuriated conservative legislators in Texas who recently tried to censor it as part of the growing white anxiety around critical race theory in the state. The author is also a self-defense instructor based in New York City. [Sara Youngblood Gregory]
4. Running from March 4 to March 13, the global Winter Paralympics in Beijing features more than 700 disabled athletes competing in 78 medal events. Since its inception in 1960, the Paralympics represent the only time that many people will see disabled sports represented in the media. For a few weeks, the disabled body is a spectacle, but also a figure of pride and excitement, with viewers eager to rack up nationalistic medal counts in sports such as biathlon, sled hockey, snowboarding, and wheelchair curling. Most viewers will not turn the lens back on themselves when the Olympic flame is extinguished. [s.e. smith]